Friday, March 9, 2018

Why Canada Defends Ukrainian Fascism

fascism politics war business nazi

Canada has a reputation for being a relatively progressive state with universal, single-payer health care, various other social benefits, and strict gun laws, similar to many European countries but quite unlike the United States. It has managed to stay out of some American wars, for example, Vietnam and Iraq, portrayed itself as a neutral “peace keeper”, pursuing a so-called policy of “multilateralism” and attempting from time to time to keep a little independent distance from the United States.

Behind this veneer of respectability lies a not so attractive reality of elite inattention to the defence of Canadian independence from the United States and intolerance toward the political and syndicalist left. Police repression against communist and left-wing unionists and other dissidents after World War I was widespread. Strong support for appeasement of Nazi Germany, overt or covert sympathy for fascism, especially in Québec, and hatred of the Soviet Union were widespread in Canada during the 1930s. The Liberal prime minister, William Lyon Mackenzie King, hobnobbed with Nazi notables including Adolf Hitler, and thought that his British counterpart Neville Chamberlain had not gone far enough in appeasing Hitlerite Germany. Mackenzie King and many others of the Canadian elite saw communism as a greater threat to Canada than fascism. As in Europe, the Canadian elite—Liberal or Conservative did not matter—was worried by the Spanish civil war (1936-1939). In Québec French public opinion under the influence of the Catholic Church hoped for fascist victory and the eradication of communism. In 1937 a Papal encyclical whipped up the Red Scare amongst French Canadian Catholics. Rejection of Soviet offers of collective security against Hitler was the obverse side of appeasement. The fear of victory over Nazi Germany in alliance with the USSR was greater than the fear of defeat against fascism. Such thoughts were either openly expressed over dinner at the local gentleman’s club or kept more discrete by people who did not want to reveal the extent of their sympathy for fascism.

Even after the Nazi invasion of the USSR in June 1941, and the formation of the Grand Alliance against the Axis, there was strong reticence amongst the governing elite in Canada toward the Soviet Union. It was a shotgun marriage, a momentary arrangement with an undesirable partner, necessitated by the over-riding threat of the Nazi Wehrmacht. “If Hitler invaded Hell,” Winston Churchill famously remarked, “I would make at least a favourable reference to the devil in the House of Commons.” Once Hitler was beaten, however, it would be back to business as usual. The Grand Alliance was a “truce”, as some of my students have proposed to me, in a longer cold war between the west and the USSR. This struggle began in November 1917 when the Bolsheviks seized power in Petrograd; it resumed after 1945 when the “truce”, or if you like, the Grand Alliance, came to a sudden end.  (more...)


Background:

fascism politics war business nazi

3 comments:

  1. As a little polish boy in Belarus my Father witnessed the Bolsheviks passing thorough his village. They raped all the girls and women who did not manage to escape and/or hide. Rather then take the beaten road, they marched through the fields ready for the harvest, destroying most of it. The German troops stationed nearby offered my Father medical help and praise accompanied by a block of chocolate - for bravery in face of painful surgery they performed on him. Oh yes, the Polish villagers feared the Nazis and the Germans, but when my Father's life was at stake, my Grandfather gave them a chance to practice their humanity. I was told that he would never turn to the Bolsheviks for help. Germans feared God, Bolsheviks feared only Stalin.

    Evil bloodthirsty Ukrainians are not an excuse for soviet barbarism. Evil Nazi murderers of civilians of many Nations are not an excuse for soviet barbarism. Putin is not Stalin.

    The main difference between Putin and the Bolsheviks, one impossible to ignore, is Putin's belief in God, when the Bolsheviks despise such faith, as they practice "social justice". Putin's reconstruction of Russia is based largely on returning to the faith of the masses, not on appealing to their anger and greed.

    1. It should not be enough to speak the word "Nazi" to excuse the often more unfathomable barbarism of the Soviet.
    2. Russia today is not what the anti-God Stalinist Soviet Union once was.
    3. The stupidity of Trudeau's government is in both - friendship with Nazi-supporters and selling out of the ignorant/asleep Nation to the ungodly global Stalinesque tyranny.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Dorota, thank you for sharing this. We must remember that the mass of Russians and Germans were VICTIMS of these ideologies, and strive to understand how they operated in their societies and in our own.

      Delete
  2. Thank you for letting me comment.
    And... I remember. I never forgot the live report I watched from Charlottesville march, where young white men were saying: We have not come here in protest against anybody, we have come here to stand up for our right to live and have families and love our faith and civilization. Anyone who claims that those were all Nazis, or that there were no violent fascists in face masks there, or that the police were not ordered to stand down as the violent attacks took place, anyone who claims that there is no anti white men rhetoric in our schools, universities, media and parliament, is simply dishonest. People who do this, radicalize these boys, who have not asked to be born, and have not asked to be born in any particular skin color, and who are constantly attacked and shamed for simply existing, and pressured to apologize for it. I am not talking here about white supremacists, a small number of whom where there as well.

    ReplyDelete